By Jai Shenoy
In an extemp speech, the basic outline alone doesn’t guarantee a concise stream of argumentation. Part of the difficulty of this event is distilling complex topics into simple terms that anyone, from a parent judge to an experienced coach, can understand. Making concise arguments requires using substructure, which is essentially how we choose to organize our main body points.
In this article, we’ll go over one of the most commonly used forms of substructure:
This type of substructure is reserved for prescriptive questions, i.e., questions that generally ask you to prescribe a solution to a given problem/condition.
Examples of Prescriptive Questions:
“What must Ukraine do to continue the fight against Russia?”
“How can the Philippines strengthen its response to China’s growing presence in the South China Sea?”
“How should the criminal justice system better address the prisoner mental health crisis?
Question words such as “How can,” “How must,” “How should,” “What should,” “What steps,” let you easily identify this substructure. Naturally, a “solution” only makes conceptual sense in the presence of a problem. Without something to solve, the idea of a solution becomes meaningless. Just like having a cure only makes sense in the presence of a disease, a solution can only be found after identifying a specific issue. Therefore, a speech about a prescriptive question requires you to solve the problem by addressing specific, underlying issues within each point.
A: Problem: a smaller, specific issue related to the larger problem in the question
Identify a specific obstacle, root cause, or deficiency that prevents the situation from being resolved
Make sure this problem is not the problem of the question but a piece of it to limit point bleed (when point content overlaps)
B: Solution: Your recommendation to fix that problem, with specific implementation and warranting
Propose a concrete, actionable, and feasible step that directly addresses the specific problem mentioned above
Get detailed with warrants by including proper nouns and at least one statistic in each subpoint
In extemp, it helps to see both the depth of how a point is written and the three-sentence story of a given point. The following examples include both “simplified points,” your standard three-sentence point explanations, and “expanded points,” complete, fully worded points. In guiding your own practice, use these examples as standards you can compare against via transcribing your own speech.
Simplified Point:
Question: How can Mali effectively combat the increase in terrorist activity?
Answer: By stopping terrorist organizing at its roots
Point 1: Addressing Local Grievances
A: Poor local conditions make young men in rural areas susceptible to terrorist recruitment
B: Appealing to international donors to get aid can alleviate financial difficulties in rural areas
C: Therefore, terrorist activity won’t increase, because there won’t be young men joining them
Expanded Point:
Question: How can Mali effectively combat the increase in terrorist activity?
Answer: By stopping terrorist organizing at its roots
Point 1: Addressing Local Grievances
Note: On-top and Signposting omitted for clarity
A: Mali's economic situation drives young men toward terrorist recruitment. The 2026 Bertelsmann Transformation Index (BTI) Report in Mali finds that, in 2023, 45.3% of Mali’s population lived in poverty. With high political instability and interethnic conflict, people without jobs rely on volatile sources of income. These local grievances result in many young men in rural areas being persuaded by JNIM and other terrorist groups through lucrative illicit activities.
B: Economic aid can alleviate these conditions. The International Crisis Group writes on June 24, 2020, that the Algiers Accord, brokered by the EU and US, ended years of separatist violence and targeted marginalized northern areas for economic reconstruction. However, the Malian junta terminated the accords. Thus, the Foreign Policy Magazine of December 3rd, 2025 demonstrates that traditional partners, such as the US and EU, have withdrawn development aid. Mali can solve terrorist recruitment by appealing to these traditional partners. The government should seek to meet peace requirements set by the US and EU, such as re-engaging in peace efforts, so development aid can once again be distributed to uplift rural areas. This way, young men will no longer turn to terrorist groups to survive.
C: So, by addressing local grievances through development aid from traditional partners, the Malian government can make terrorist recruitment a tactic of the past.
Simplified Point:
Question: How can late night television protect itself from an increasingly hostile White House?
Answer: By adapting to circumvent the White House’s hostility
Point 1: Expanding Direct-to-Consumer Distribution
A: Traditional television is susceptible to censorship and FCC broadcast licensing challenges
B: Direct-to-consumer streaming platforms allow late night television to be shared without those risks
C: Late night television survives and has an expanded viewership
Expanded Point:
Question: How can late night television protect itself from an increasingly hostile White House?
Answer: By adapting to circumvent the White House’s hostility.
Point 1: Expanding Direct-to-Consumer Distribution
A: The traditional television ecosystem is susceptible to censorship. The New York Times on February 19, 2026, elucidates that new enforcement by the FCC of the Equal Time rule is causing media companies to self-censor to avoid the FCC revoking their media broadcasting licenses. Since polarized views from hosts like Jimmy Kimmel may also lead to advertiser boycotts and network cancellations, the middleman nature of traditional television exposes late night television to the whims of the White House.
B: To fight back, late night television must adopt direct-to-consumer media. Business Insider on October 13, 2025, reveals that The Late Show with Jimmy Kimmel has already seen success in this, with his YouTube episodes averaging 1.5-2.5 million viewers nightly. Kimmel has also used YouTube to dodge censorship, with PBS reporting on September 10 of this year that Kimmel’s special interview with Talarico, in the face of regulatory scrutiny, was only published on YouTube. Other late night television should do the same, avoiding regulatory oversight through streaming and cable platforms that don’t risk censorship.
C: By doing so, not only will Late Night Television preserve its voice, but also help preserve the very essence of opinion itself.
All three points of a prescriptive are to be unique and distinct. Like any good speech, the points should not overlap. As a result, the problem in each point must be a smaller, unique underlying issue related to the larger problem in the question. This sets the stage for a targeted solution that solves the exact problem identified right before. NO subpoint should EVER be the same as another, whether it's a problem or a solution subpoint. This way, you reduce point bleed and confirm to judges you are not being repetitive.
When working on a solution, it is important to be feasible and specific. Rather than just saying, “X government should spend more on a specific sector” and focusing on where those funds should go, it would be smart to also elaborate and explain how exactly they would obtain those funds to begin the transformative process in the first place, such as through grants and concessional loans, public-private partnerships, etc. Clarifying the “how” is just as crucial as explaining the “what.” If you cannot answer how a solution will be enacted, it is probably best to avoid using it or admit your solution isn’t perfect. For example, adding phrases like “it’s not a silver bullet/panacea…”, etc can go a long way in adding an element of realism to your solutions and increasing your analytical credibility.
The solutions you propose in your speech don't necessarily have to result in guaranteed real-world outcomes. After all, if a solution were truly effective and practical, it likely would have already been implemented. However, you must still avoid suggesting solutions that are outright impossible. Mentioning specific pieces of legislation, mandates, laws, people, organizations, timelines and any other details can also all add a layer of nuance that can help distinguish yourself from other competitors.
You can also make solutions through your own analysis. Simply, if a source says Medicare funding in the US has a gap of $100 million, your B can say the solution is to increase funding by $101 million. This is a simplified example, but creating unique solutions through what you know and find in research can make you stand out through creative reasoning and argumentation.
Your thesis can help build your problem-solution structure. Make sure your thesis acts as an umbrella statement, i.e., a catch-all that encompasses the solutions of all three of your points. It's okay if this means your thesis is broad, but that level of strategic framing lets the audience easily follow the problem-solution in each of your points.
If it isn't obvious already, an exceptionally executed problem-solution substructure has a lot of details and burdens that must be addressed, so it's important to economize your words and be mindful of time allocation. Through consistent practice, anyone can master the Problem-Solution substructure.