By Jai Shenoy
In an extemp speech, the basic outline alone doesn’t guarantee a concise stream of argumentation. Part of the difficulty of this event is distilling complex topics into simple terms that anyone, from a parent judge to an experienced coach, can understand. Making concise arguments requires using substructure, which is essentially how we choose to organize our main body points.
In this article, we’ll go over one of the more niche forms of substructure, which is often seen as the most difficult:
Comparative Substructure is the most difficult type of extemp substructure. It relies upon setting up multiple actors in the introduction that you compare and select to fit the superlative criterion set up by the question. This type of substructure is reserved for comparative questions: questions that ask you to select one specific actor out of multiple possibilities that is most suitable in the context of the question
Examples of Comparative Questions:
“Who will win Panama’s presidential election?”
“If he steps down, who should replace Keir Starmer?”
“Which nation is best positioned to negotiate diplomatic talks between the factions in conflict within Syria?”
Category Buzzwords: “Who,” “Which,” “What candidate/country,” any question that asks which actor, candidate, or entity is best positioned for a certain situation.
Declaring a 'best’ choice only makes conceptual sense in the presence of a metric. Without a clear standard for evaluation, the act of choosing becomes arbitrary and meaningless. Just as a winner cannot be declared without a finish line, an entity cannot be deemed optimal without a set criterion. Therefore, in a comparative speech, you must not only name your selection, but establish the specific metric that proves they stand alone as the most qualified answer to the question. That is why in each point there should be a criterion component (the metric) and a comparison component (what actor fills that metric the best). This framework shares a very similar substructure to expectation verification.
A: Criterion (Define a specific standard for evaluation and explain why it is a relevant way to judge the options)
B: Comparison (Evaluate how your choice best fulfills that metric compared to others)
However, in doing this structure, you must also lay out and specifically mention all the options in your background.
Question: What member country will prove to be the most valuable asset to the NATO alliance?
Answer: The United States because of its superior levels of assistance
Point 1: Financial Support
A: In order for NATO to truly thrive, they must have a proper financial backbone, as it is this funding that enables the acquisition of emerging and disruptive technologies, such as AI and quantum computing. Therefore, to remain NATO’s most valuable asset, a country must fulfill the financial needs of the alliance.
B: The US accounts for 62% of the alliance’s $1.59 trillion in combined defense expenditures, proving to be a spending powerhouse that allows the alliance to maintain unparalleled global military reach and rapid-response capabilities. The second-highest NATO spender, Germany, spends less than 10% of what the United States does with a budget of $93.75 billion annually. The United Kingdom closely trails that budget, spending around $90.51 billion annually.
Question: Which nation is best positioned to lead the global development of artificial intelligence?
Answer: China because they have unparalleled resources best equipped to do so
Point 1: Unmatched STEM Pipeline
A: Highly specialized human capital is often the primary factor of technological supremacy. It is advanced expertise in STEM (Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics), fields that constantly intersect with AI, that allow industries to constantly innovate and ensure models are secure. In order to lead the global development of artificial intelligence, one must have STEM doctorates and other academic accolades to guarantee sustainability and long-term growth.
B: China is outpacing the US in producing STEM degrees, awarding more than 50,000 STEM doctorates in 2022. This total represents more than double what China produced in 2007, the year it first overtook the US. In fact, the US was expected to face a deficit of around 3.5 million STEM workers in 2025.
It is important to note that you must not only explain why a certain actor is likely to achieve something, but why the other potential actors are less likely to do so. For example, for the question “Who Will Win the 2028 US Presidential Election”, you must mention not only why Gavin Newsom (for example) will likely succeed, but why specific contenders like JB Pritzker and Kamala Harris will likely fall short of their goals. You don’t have to mention all potential candidates/actors, just a few. Ultimately, your speech should be centered around one main entity, but every point should still reference the other options to prove they are less optimal.
It is ideal to mention the multiple potential candidates in the introduction before delving into the main points. By doing this, when you bring them up later in the speech, you will not have to waste time introducing them. Instead, you can immediately talk about them specifically relative to the point you are on. This approach also ensures the audience is not caught off guard when a candidate is suddenly introduced in the middle of a speech.
Overall, comparative substructure may be daunting, but through practice and efficient word economy, you can make it work.